My summer assignment
using the RTNDF grant was at KVUE-TV, Channel 24, in Austin, Texas, under
the sponsorship of News Director Frank Volpicella. The assignment lasted
from July 11 to August 17, 2001, with my activities primarily focused on
producing.
Here are my impressions:
I have been to
about 20 different television newsrooms over the past ten years. In most
of those newsrooms, I spent at least a day observing while I conducted
interviews for my dissertation. The impressions that were formed then
have been altered somewhat by this more recent experience made possible
by the RTNDF grant.
What stood out to me
during my dissertation research (on "Decision-Making in Television
Newsrooms: The Rationale for Live-On-The-Scene News Reports") was
how market-driven, promotions-oriented many of the news managers' content
choices were. Perhaps that impression was based on incomplete information.
Perhaps it was a result of having only a cursory view. Or perhaps it was
shaped in large part by the nature of the questions I asked. In any case,
all of the news managers I talked to had an intense interest in marketing.
Much of the news content, I observed, was based on how effective the stories
and visuals were in attracting and holding viewers' attention. What I found
lacking, to my dismay, was attention to good ol' fashioned journalism.
The RTNDF grant
gave me an opportunity to spend more time in a single newsroom and see
decisions over several weeks. I now feel more comforted that, at this station
at least, journalistic values are still a prime consideration. Marketing
and promotions are certainly given weight, but a story's impact on people's
lives is given at least equal consideration. That view was formed over
time and certainly not during the first week.
The first week
of news content seemed to be dominated by pet stories -- especially the
mutilation of cats. I simply wasn't persuaded that these stories deserved
so much attention, but perhaps my own lack of pet attachments played a
role in my not seeing this as a big impact story.
In time, though,
I grew to respect the news menus I saw taking shape on a day-to-day basis.
The staples of news coverage -- education, government, crime, fires, etc.
-- were covered and covered well.
The news department
consists of several young, dedicated people. In a station of this size,
the staff has specialized roles but many of them are quite capable of wearing
different hats when necessary. For example, anyone in the newsroom can
be called on to run the assignment desk (even a lowly intern, like me).
The assignment editor occasionally runs camera. The anchors write. And,
in a crunch, producers edit tape. That kind of versatility is great to
see. When I teach students, I expect them to learn a wide range of skills.
Now that I see even a big market station, like this one, expecting the
same of its employees, I have confirmation that versatility is a huge plus.
Even the news director
rolls up his sleeves when necessary. One day there was breaking news and
the evening newscast deadline was looming, so he got on the phones, along
with the assignment desk and producers, in search of information. Another
time, the evening executive producer called in sick, so Frank stepped in
to oversee the newscasts, poring over every line and video cue before printing
the stories.
It has been my
observation that Frank is very much a teacher in the newsroom. I've seen
plenty of one-on-one conferences with the newsroom staff. And I've heard
some interesting ethical discussions. For example, a photographer's treatment
of a news story was questioned because he had shown the faces of Hispanic
and black inmates but had framed the faces of white inmates where they
couldn't be seen. Another time, there was a debate over whether the station
should continue to identify a woman arrested for abandoning her baby who
later died. Complicating the matter was her assertion that the baby was
the result of rape. Should the station continue to identify the woman since
she was a possible rape victim, or was it okay since the woman now faced
criminal charges? (Answer: her name was used in subsequent stories, but
not her mug shot.)
In short, Frank
is a hands-on news director, and I respect that. And I respect the work
of the professionals in this news department. I made a point to have conversations
with a wide variety of people to find out how they fit into the overall
picture. Everyone -- producers, executive producers, tape editors, promotions
writers, the planning editor, the assignment editors, the webmaster, the
assistant news director, reporters and photographers -- graciously took
the time, when asked, to describe their jobs, their backgrounds and their
influences.
A kind of assurance
has been realized from this experience: an assurance that the education
that we're providing at txstate is not far off the mark. We go through the
same kind of process when we pull together a half-hour live newscast. Good
news writing, effective storytelling, ethical values and a high degree
of versatility are important in either domain. Thank goodness for that!
The greatest divergence,
without a doubt, is technology. Television stations, like KVUE, are certainly
better equipped to deliver news. And just as they did years ago when I
embarked on my dissertation research, microwave and satellite trucks still
intrigue me. The "real world" has much better toys, and I feel
a serious deficiency when it comes to our ability to train students to
handle live situations.
My most exciting
day of the internship occurred when a breaking news event was covered live.
One day the assignment desk learned of a major brush fire in northern Hays
County. I asked where in northern Hays County. "Along Hilliard Road"
was the response. Wow! That's near my neighborhood, some 42 miles from
the station. Off we go to the scene in a satellite truck and car with me
leading the way into the Texas Hill Country. When the photographers were
permitted to get a closer view of the fire, I went with them. Outstanding!!The grass and trees were still smoldering. Hot spots were all around
us.Helicopters were buzzing
above us. For three consecutive days, the fires, which consumed almost
one-thousand acres, led the local newscasts.Fortunately, no one was seriously hurt and no homes were lost.Eventually, the fires were put out and the story had a happy ending.
Thanks for the
opportunity. The fellowship has definitely been worthwhile. I hope other
broadcast journalism professors are given a chance to participate as I
did.